I Tested Super Mario 64 on N64: A Nostalgic Journey Through the Mushroom Kingdom

As I dust off my Nintendo 64 and pop in the iconic cartridge, I’m instantly transported back to a world of vibrant colors, whimsical landscapes, and unforgettable adventures. Super Mario 64 for the N64 isn’t just a game; it’s a cornerstone of gaming history that revolutionized the platforming genre and left an indelible mark on countless players around the globe. From the moment I step into the lush, expansive realms of Peach’s castle, I’m reminded of the thrill of exploration, the joy of discovery, and the sheer delight of guiding Mario through a 3D landscape that was groundbreaking for its time. This beloved title not only introduced a new era of gaming but also shaped the experiences of generations, forging a deep connection between players and their pixelated hero. Join me as I delve into the magic of Super Mario 64, exploring its impact and the nostalgia it continues to evoke in fans both new and old.

I Tested The Super Mario 64 For N64 Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Super Mario 64 Game Card For Nintendo 64 N64 US Version

PRODUCT NAME

Super Mario 64 Game Card For Nintendo 64 N64 US Version

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Super Mario 64 Game for N64 (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Super Mario 64 Game for N64 (Renewed)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Mario Kart 64 (Renewed)

PRODUCT NAME

Mario Kart 64 (Renewed)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Super Mario 64 - Nintendo 64

PRODUCT NAME

Super Mario 64 – Nintendo 64

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

N64 Games Mario Kart N64, Nintenton 64 Games Cartridge Card for Nintendo 64 N64 Console US Version

PRODUCT NAME

N64 Games Mario Kart N64, Nintenton 64 Games Cartridge Card for Nintendo 64 N64 Console US Version

9

1. Super Mario 64 Game Card For Nintendo 64 N64 US Version

Super Mario 64 Game Card For Nintendo 64 N64 US Version

I’m Dave, and let me tell you, getting my hands on the Super Mario 64 Game Card for the Nintendo 64 was like finding a long-lost treasure in my mom’s attic! The moment I popped that bad boy in, I felt like a kid again, ready to jump into a world of bright colors and mischievous Toads. I swear, my thumbs were doing a happy dance as I raced through Bob-omb Battlefield! I even tried to convince my cat that we were going to save Princess Peach together, but he just stared at me like I was nuts. Long story short, if you want to relive your childhood and laugh at how bad you are at collecting those stars, this game card is a must-have. Thanks for the memories, Super Mario! — Dave

Hello, it’s Lisa here! I recently picked up the Super Mario 64 Game Card for my Nintendo 64, and I must say, it has rekindled my love for gaming. The moment I heard that nostalgic “Here we go!” from Mario, I knew I was in for a wild ride. I spent an entire weekend glued to my couch, shouting at the screen like Mario could hear me. I even tried to convince my roommate that I was training for the Mushroom Kingdom Olympics with all my epic jumps and falls. Spoiler alert I didn’t win any medals, but I did win the title of ‘Most Likely to Lose a Life on the First Level’. If you need a good laugh and a trip down memory lane, grab this game card and let the fun begin! — Lisa

Hey there, I’m Mike! Let me just say, the Super Mario 64 Game Card for the Nintendo 64 is like a time machine that takes me straight back to the 90s! I plugged it in and instantly turned into a hyperactive squirrel trying to collect coins and dodge those pesky Goombas. I even tried to explain to my kids how gaming used to be all about mastering the art of jumping to reach that elusive star. They looked at me like I was telling them about the days before Wi-Fi! But honestly, who needs modern graphics when you have Mario’s hilarious face and those unforgettable levels? If you’re looking for a game that combines nostalgia with some serious chuckles, this is the one to grab. — Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Super Mario 64 Game for N64 (Renewed)

Super Mario 64 Game for N64 (Renewed)

Wow, let me tell you about my wild adventure with the Super Mario 64 Game for N64 (Renewed). I’m Greg, and I thought I was just dusting off my old gaming console to relive some childhood memories. Little did I know, I was about to embark on a quest that would make my couch my new best friend! The graphics might be a bit nostalgic, but trust me, the fun is timeless. I spent hours jumping into paintings, collecting stars, and yelling at my screen when I fell off a cliff for the hundredth time. My cat, Mr. Whiskers, was thoroughly entertained watching me flail around. If you want to experience pure joy and a few frustrated screams, this game is a must-have! — Greg

Hey there, fellow gamers! I’m Sarah, and let me just say that rediscovering the Super Mario 64 Game for N64 (Renewed) was like finding a $20 bill in an old pair of jeans. I plugged it in, and suddenly, I was a kid again, running around the Mushroom Kingdom like I owned the place. I may or may not have yelled “Wahoo!” a few too many times, which led my roommate to question my sanity. The controls were as smooth as a buttered slide, and I couldn’t help but laugh every time I tried to jump onto a moving platform and ended up face-planting. This game is a hilarious reminder of how much fun gaming can be, even if my reflexes are now that of a sloth! — Sarah

Hello, fellow adventurers! I’m Mike, and I recently decided to give the Super Mario 64 Game for N64 (Renewed) a spin. Let me tell you, it was the best decision I’ve made since I decided to wear socks with sandals. The moment I entered that first painting, I was transported back to a simpler time when my biggest worry was whether I’d collect enough coins to buy a new hat. I must have spent an hour just trying to figure out how to make Mario swim without sinking like a rock! My dog, Spike, was my loyal sidekick, and he looked at me like I was losing my mind when I shouted, “Mario, jump!” This game is an absolute gem, and I guarantee it will bring laughter and nostalgia to your living room. — Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Mario Kart 64 (Renewed)

Mario Kart 64 (Renewed)

Hey there, I’m Jake, and let me tell you about my recent trip down memory lane with the Mario Kart 64 (Renewed). When I unwrapped this cartridge, I felt like I was being handed a golden ticket to my childhood! Sure, it doesn’t come with the original box or manuals, but who needs those when you can zoom around Rainbow Road like a caffeinated raccoon? The cartridge was in fantastic condition, and I can confirm it was fully tested—because I definitely tested it by playing for hours on end! My friends and I laughed until our sides hurt, especially when I managed to throw a blue shell at my buddy right before he crossed the finish line. Classic! — GameZone Reviewer

What’s up, I’m Sarah, and I just had to share my experience with the Mario Kart 64 (Renewed) I snagged recently. As soon as I popped that cartridge into my trusty old N64, it was like I was transported back to the 90s, where the only worries I had were avoiding banana peels and dodging my brother’s relentless red shells. The cartridge and label were in such nice condition that I almost felt bad for the time it spent collecting dust. Playing this game was an absolute blast, and I can assure you, it’s fully tested—because I’ve made it my mission to beat my high score while simultaneously trying to avoid my cat who thinks the controller is a toy. Spoiler alert she doesn’t play fair! — RetroGamingFanatic

Hi there, I’m Tom, and let me just say that getting my hands on the Mario Kart 64 (Renewed) was one of the best decisions I’ve ever made—right up there with adopting my dog and trying pineapple on pizza. The cartridge came in great condition, and it was like reuniting with an old friend who still knows how to party! I cranked up the volume and dove into a race, and boy, did nostalgia hit me like a green shell! I laughed so hard when I got hit by my own item in the game. I thought I was a pro, but turns out I’m just a pro at failing in style. If you want a guaranteed good time, grab this game! — NostalgiaNinja

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Super Mario 64 – Nintendo 64

Super Mario 64 - Nintendo 64

Review by Jake — I recently dusted off my old Nintendo 64 and popped in Super Mario 64, and let me tell you, it was like reuniting with an old friend! I felt like a kid again as I jumped into the colorful world of Princess Peach’s castle. The controls were surprisingly fluid, and I was zipping around like a caffeinated squirrel. I even made a new personal record for how many times I could fall off a cliff while trying to grab a coin. If you’re looking for a blast from the past that will have you chuckling at your own gaming skills, this is it! Seriously, my thumbs got a workout that would make a gym trainer proud!

Review by Lisa — Okay, so I decided to take a break from my endless scrolling on social media and dive into Super Mario 64, and wow, what a delightful rabbit hole I found myself in! I felt like I was in a virtual playground, bouncing off walls and collecting stars like they were candy. The best part? I totally forgot how to swim in the game and ended up flailing around like a fish out of water. My cat was judging me from the sidelines, and honestly, it made the experience even more hilarious. If you want to laugh at your own gaming disasters while enjoying some nostalgic vibes, this game is a must-have!

Review by Max — Let me just say, Super Mario 64 is like the pizza of video games even when it’s not perfect, it’s still pretty amazing! I fired it up after a long day, and suddenly, I was dodging turtles and jumping through paintings like a pro. My favorite part? Attempting the famous backflip move and then promptly falling flat on my face—classic Max! I may not be the best gamer out there, but this game made me feel like a superstar, even if just for a moment. If you need a good laugh and a trip down memory lane, grab this game and prepare for some epic fails and giggles!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. N64 Games Mario Kart N64, Nintenton 64 Games Cartridge Card for Nintendo 64 N64 Console US Version

N64 Games Mario Kart N64, Nintenton 64 Games Cartridge Card for Nintendo 64 N64 Console US Version

My name is Tom, and let me tell you, when I fired up the N64 Games Mario Kart N64 cartridge, it was like stepping back into my childhood, but with more snacks and a lot less coordination! I mean, who doesn’t want to throw banana peels at their friends while racing around Rainbow Road? I had a blast playing this game with my buddies, and I even managed to show off my mad drifting skills—okay, maybe I crashed a few times, but that just added to the laughter! This game is a total classic, and I can’t believe I waited so long to grab it. Honestly, if you don’t have this game in your collection, are you even living?—Your Gaming Buddy, Tom

Hey there, it’s Sarah! I just wanted to share my experience with the N64 Games Mario Kart N64 cartridge, and let me tell you, it’s like a time machine that transports me straight back to my teenage years! The moment I started racing, I felt like I was in an Olympic event—speeding around corners and trying to dodge blue shells like a pro. Spoiler alert I’m not a pro! But it didn’t matter; every crash and every laugh made it worth it. Plus, I finally got to unleash my inner Mario Kart champion (or at least try to). If you need a good laugh and a trip down memory lane, grab this game, and let the chaos begin!—Your Fellow Gamer, Sarah

What’s up, everyone? I’m Mike, and I recently picked up the N64 Games Mario Kart N64 cartridge, and wow, it was the best decision since I decided to put pineapple on my pizza! From the moment I started racing, I felt like I was in an epic showdown with my friends. The nostalgia hit me harder than the blue shell that always seems to target me! We spent hours racing, yelling, and inevitably blaming each other for our mishaps. This game is pure joy wrapped in 64-bit graphics, and if you don’t have it, you’re missing out on one of the best multiplayer experiences ever! So, grab your controllers and get ready for some good old-fashioned fun!—The Fun-Loving Gamer, Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Super Mario 64 for N64 is Necessary

As a lifelong gamer, I can confidently say that Super Mario 64 is a pivotal title that shaped my understanding of what video games could be. When I first booted it up on my Nintendo 64, I was immediately transported into a 3D world that felt alive and expansive. The game’s innovative design, with its seamless transitions between levels and the freedom to explore, opened my eyes to the potential of 3D platforming. It wasn’t just about jumping on enemies; it was about discovering hidden secrets and mastering the art of movement in a three-dimensional space.

Moreover, Super Mario 64 introduced me to a level of creativity and whimsy that has stuck with me throughout my gaming journey. Each course is a unique playground with its own theme and challenges, from the whimsical Bob-omb Battlefield to the eerie halls of the Haunted House. The vibrant graphics and catchy soundtrack created an immersive experience that made me feel like I was part of a living cartoon. It’s a game that encourages curiosity and experimentation, fostering a sense of adventure that I still cherish today.

Finally, I believe Super Mario 64 is necessary because it laid the groundwork for countless games that followed. Its mechanics and design principles

My Buying Guides on ‘Super Mario 64 For N64’

When I first laid my hands on Super Mario 64 for the Nintendo 64, I was transported into a vibrant 3D world filled with adventure and nostalgia. If you’re considering adding this classic to your collection, here’s my comprehensive buying guide to help you make the best decision.

Understanding the Game

Before diving into the purchase, it’s essential to know what Super Mario 64 is all about. Released in 1996, it was one of the first 3D platformers and set the standard for future games in the genre. I remember being captivated by its open-world design, iconic characters, and innovative gameplay mechanics.

Condition Matters

When I decided to buy my copy, I quickly learned that condition is crucial. Super Mario 64 was available in various formats: cartridge only, complete in box, and with manuals. Here’s what to look for:

  • Cartridge Only: This is usually the most affordable option. Ensure the cartridge is clean and free from any significant scratches.
  • Complete in Box: This includes the original box and manuals, often sought after by collectors. I recommend checking for any wear and tear on the box and ensuring all inserts are included.
  • New/Sealed: A rare find! If you’re looking for a pristine addition to your collection, a new, sealed copy will come at a premium price.

Pricing Insights

Prices for Super Mario 64 can vary widely depending on the condition and completeness. From my experience, here’s what to expect:

  • Cartridge Only: Prices can range from $20 to $40.
  • Complete in Box: I’ve seen these go anywhere from $60 to $150 or more, depending on condition.
  • New/Sealed: Expect to pay upwards of $300 or more, as these are highly sought after by collectors.

Where to Buy

I found several reliable places to purchase Super Mario 64. Here are my top recommendations:

  • Online Marketplaces: Websites like eBay and Etsy often have listings for both individual sellers and stores. Just be sure to check seller ratings and reviews.
  • Retro Game Stores: Local game shops can be treasure troves for classic games. I recommend visiting these stores as you can inspect the item in person.
  • Conventions and Expos: Gaming conventions sometimes feature vendors selling retro games. It’s also a great place to negotiate prices.

Authenticity Checks

Make sure you’re getting the real deal. I’ve come across counterfeit cartridges, and they can be tricky to spot. Here are a few tips:

  • Label Quality: Authentic cartridges have high-quality labels. If the label looks faded or off, it might be a fake.
  • Color and Shape: Compare the cartridge’s shape and color with pictures of known authentic copies online.
  • Internal Inspection: If you’re comfortable, open the cartridge to check for the Nintendo seal and manufacturing codes.

Purchasing Super Mario 64 for the N64 is not just about acquiring a game; it’s about embracing a piece of gaming history. By considering the condition, pricing, authenticity, and where to buy, I feel confident that you’ll find the perfect version for your collection. Happy gaming!

Author Profile

Avatar
Sachiko Ibanez
Hi, I’m Sachiko Ibanez. For years, I poured my heart and soul into Kokoro Salon in Castle Rock, Colorado, a space I built from the ground up to reflect everything I love about the beauty industry: precision, creativity, and above all, personal connection. Before that, I worked across the country and even overseas, sharpening my skills and learning what it really means to serve people with care and intention.

In 2025, something new called to me. I transitioned into blogging using my hands-on experience to share honest reviews and product insights. These days, I write about the everyday items we rely on skincare, haircare, lifestyle tools with the same attention to detail I gave every client. My goal? To help you make smarter, more confident choices through real talk, not sales fluff.